Saturday, December 5, 2015

Forwarded by a civilian technologist/scientist who admires the Armed Forces

Beautiful article written by Brig Narender Kumar


I had an opportunity to glance through IDSA study which has been extensively quoted by the Pay Commission to deny or scale down the dues to Armed Forces personals. But I am surprised that the IDSA study did not mention that in US and UK soldiers get their pensions at the rate of 75% of their salary. Also when the US & European nations deploy their soldiers in war like situation or disaster relief operations  they do not pay income tax.

I wish the study had made the mention that even in kargil war officers and JCos paid the income tax, same is the case for J&K and NE insurgency. I was told that the income tax is also charged from the last salary of a martyr. which is nothing short of national shame. I wish these facts should have been included. Since the IDSA study compared the purchasing power of other country soldiers vis a vis India. 

But  the pay commission did not use this analogy while calculating and doling out three increments to IAS , IPS & IFS. A soldier gets 31500/-- for serving in Siachen but a central cadre officer gets 50000 to 70000 for serving in so called difficult area such as Shillong, Imphal and Guwahati @ 30% of their salary (In Spite of the acknowledgement made by pay commission cell that most difficult area to serve with no parallel is Siachen).

I was BGS during Uttrakhand Disaster relief operations, three DCs were literally not available during the critical days of disaster. Same was the case with SDMs and tehsildars.  The SDM who was deputed to go to Kedarnath emerged only after five days of relief operation in vogue. DC prefered to park himself inside the Joshimath camp so that public can't reach him.  When DC was forced to at least go and see the condition on ground, the gentleman did not get down from the helicopter fearing that he might not be allowed by public to board the helicopter. DC uttarkashi did not feel safe to visit and see the conditions of pilgrims at Gangotri and harsil. The pilgrims kept asking "where is the administration, if the army has to do everything why is government spending national wealth on them". That is the condition of our so called elite.

It is sad that the  public of India does not even know  why a soldier defy the logic and conventions? Why does he risk his life? In-spite of the fact that there is no written rule where a soldier is suppose to die while performing his duty, yet he does so. It is ethos, tradition and character of soldiers that prompt them to do so. Second factor is  because he knows he is not a government servant, he is an elite and serve the nation. He also knows that he is the last bastion and pillar which nation is dependent upon. 

Every other department has failed and and can fail, but nation can still recover. But if the soldiers fail, the nation will fail. No other government agency can redeem it. it is elitism that separates soldiers from the rest. Unfortunately over a period of time the elitism has been killed and soldier is repeatedly told he is a government servant that too semi skilled. Whereas soldering is most complex, technical and skilful job which is unparalleled.  It is an old saying that the day a soldier start behaving like a government servant it is beginning of erosion of foundation of a nation.

I must quote the examples of US/ Uk and other countries. When the body of a martyr is brought back to US. The captain of the aircraft makes the announcement prior to taking off "we are privileged to fly back martyr  ---xyz--- on his last journey back home" On arrival of the body of the martyr on US soil and his native place.water canon salute is given. Crew  line up on tar to pay last respect. The CEO or the highest authority of the air port receives the body along with the Guard. All passenger stand in line till body is moved out. 

But when the body of Maj varadarajan was being flown from Srinagar to Chennai, the Captain was requested by the officer accompanying the body to announce that maj Vardrajan is on board on his last journey back home, the captain of the aircraft refused to announce that he is privileged to fly the martyr on his last journey back home, saying it will send a kind of bad feeling and omen to people flying and thus he will not do so. Incidentally there was another pilot who wrote  small message of regretting such an incident. 

The body of soldiers are taken from the cargo gate which is indeed an insult. And we continue to accept it without highlighting it. 

It is only Mr Chandrashekher MP Rajya Sabha who is fighting a lone battle.

We need to introspect and make the nation aware. Profession of soldiering is not routine government job. It is different an elitism is must or else, we will have soldier also behaving like other government staff such as the famous DCs of Uttrakhand. 

Can nation afford soldiers behaving like government servants? I don't think so. 

I heard in the news today that Drs did not turn up in Chennai, the government staff did not turn up for discharging their duties...... But soldiers did their best whole day. Is it that there lives are not precious?  
I think those of us who have the opportunity to share and proliferate our views must do it.

Also, who was looking after soldier's families when they were out providing assistance to all.........

(Source- e-mail from Ravi Mani) 


  1. Shameless civil servants thru the 7th cpc and indifferent DM and rest of the government will not mind to calculate the cost of special clothing and other needs of soldiers at Sai Chin as part of the CTC of soldiers to say that they are being paid more than they deserve and don't be surprised if some of them dare say the soldiers are happy to be posted there just to earn some extra money. Chullu bhar paani me Doob maro --- .sare ke sare Jo soldiers ko aisa treatment justify karte hain .........

  2. It is a wonderful article. We must appreciate our Brigadier and the Civilian scientist.
    Not only veterans but all citizens should read.
    Well done.
    Sgt.s.Kanthiah, air veteran, Exwel Trust

  3. Dear Brig Sahib,
    You have written the truth in our country soldiers respect comes when war broke out or natural calamities forces the country. When there is pay commision they consider them unskilled /semi skilled soldiers . It is very unfortunate for Indian Defence force personnel .

  4. Very true. Everyone must read this. In fact it should be telecast on TV and radio.

  5. IAS,IPS,IRS are completed their training in Lal bahadur shastri academy, initially they will posted as a ground soldiers in field and
    high altitudes for three years.

  6. Why the Brig is not writing about circular 547 and 548 which is totally for officers not for pbor. Officers have already received 3 to 4 lakh before Diwali and pbor are waiting for 3 to 4 thousands only. What a good decision by Govt ? Officers received arrears from 01.01,2006 to 23.09.2012 and pbor have not received arrears from 01.01.2006 to 30.06.2009 with a imaginary tables A to C enclosed with circular 547.

  7. You said it, "soldering is most complex, technical and skilful job which is unparalleled." Still a soldier is considered by the government as a unskilled labour.