NEW DELHI: Military officers are up in arms against the Govt's decision to implement recommendations of 7th Central Pay Commission on disability pension and are not buying the claim that the compensation package has increased. How justified are their demands?
The Govt's decision to discard 6th CPC's percentage -based determination - 30% of last drawn basic pay for 100% disability - with a slab-based one in the 7th CPC is intended to bring more equity among different ranks risking their lives in battlefield operations.
After 6thCPC, when percentage-based calculation was introduced, for 100% disability at the lowest rank for jawans, the disability pension went up from Rs 1,550 to Rs 3,138, while at the highest level for officers, it rose from Rs 2,600 to Rs 27,000, more than 10 times.
The disparity seemed to reflect in disability being reported in the higher ranks of brigadier and above. Officers retiring with disability in the Armed forces increased from 13% in 2007-08 to 20% in 2013-14. On the other hand, jawans and JCOs retiring with disability decreased from 19% in 2007-08 to 7% in 2013-14.
There are 13.2 lakh soldiers and other ranks who stand to lose from this skewed system that seems to benefit 66,700 officers (strength of the 3 Services). Military officers have been demanding that the government make an upward revision of disability pension from the 6th pay level of 30% of last pay drawn to 50% of last pay in cases of 100% disability.
But this would mean a retired general with 100% disability will draw pension equal to the pay of a serving general. A soldier at the bottom of the curve will get an additional Rs 10,000-15,000 per month, besides the normal pension, in case of 100% disability. Disability pension is in addition to normal pension.
As per the new slab of the 7th pay panel, officers of the three Services, including honorary commissioned officers, will get Rs 27,000 per month disability pension in addition to normal pension in case of 100% disability. Subedar major, subedar, naib subedar and equivalent ranks in other Services would get Rs 17,000 a month; havildar, naik and sepoy would get Rs 12,000. The equity between the highest paid disability pension to officers and at the lowest rank has been restored to the pre-6th pay panel level.
According to the 7th CPC, the ratio of maximum to minimum compensation for disability across the ranks witnessed a decline from 4.85 prior to the 3rd CPC to 1.67 after the 5th CPC. But as a consequence of implementation of the percentage-based system in the 6th CPC, the ratio of maximum to minimum was reversed to 8.60.
After implementation of the percentage-based disability pension, it was noticed that more senior officers in the rank of brigadier and above were claiming disability and "Service officers invalidated out and one who served on and retired in due course got the same quantum of disability element" in their monthly remuneration package.
Top Comment
With terror strikes becoming daily routine specially in j &k , and naval infected areas chances of getting disable have increased. Govt should not try to save money by cutting disability pension.
(Source-FB Post of Jayvant Walawalker/TOI)
What about equity with a civilian officer sitting in office and getting disability. Please tell how he gets disability in first place...can anyone give statistics of civilian officers with disability, rate of rejection by audit people if any, and reasons for disability...
ReplyDeleteAnd why not equity between different posts of civilians..reduce disability for civilian officers also and bring it to based on slab system. Government will save a lot of money too.
ReplyDeleteIts a liers world. Right from the govt to the timesofindia.
ReplyDeleteInstead of comparing equal disability pension with civilians, veteran officiers community should fight for equal disability pension for PBORs at par with disabled ofgicers
ReplyDeleteWhat ever given to defence forces it should always asked by civilians so only civilian are beneficiary rest all are no claim arises as they are the rule makers
ReplyDeleteThe article is nothing but a paid piece by MOD Babus through Sh Thakur.This is apparent from the fact that there is no mention of the DP to civilians and the logic why they get it in the first place. Instead, a dirty attemt at comparing the DP of officers and pbors has been made so as to drive a wedge within the armed forces. These Babus have failed everywhere and are squarely responsible for the problems being faced by the nation. And now, they are unashamedly stooping to such low levels. I think an inquiry needs to be conducted to find the people behind this type of write up in the media and their true motives.
ReplyDeleteThis write-up -amounts terrorist act and therefore merits surgical military strike.
ReplyDelete